To read our full disclaimer, click here.
In 1984 Warren Buffett gave a talk at Columbia called “The Superinvestors of Graham-and-Doddsville”.
The point of it was to take apart the idea that nobody beats the market except by luck.
The first investor he held up as evidence was Walter Schloss.
Schloss never went to college. He started on Wall Street as a runner in 1934, took Ben Graham’s courses, and then went to work for him at Graham-Newman. In 1956 he set up his own partnership.
By the time Buffett wrote about him, that partnership had compounded at 21.3% a year since 1956 (16.1% for the limited partners after his share). He kept running it until 2002.
Over the whole stretch he compounded at about 15.3% a year. The S&P 500 did about 10%.
That gap sounds small until you run it. At 15.3% for 47 years, $1 turns into roughly $805. At 10%, it turns into about $88.
Buffett came back to him in his 2006 letter and said there was “no possibility that what Walter achieved over 47 years was due to chance.”
He also never ran it like a big fund. In a 1994 memo to friends, Buffett pointed out that Walter’s office costs for the year were around $11,000. The partnership made $19 million.
A month before that memo, on 10 March 1994, Schloss typed up a list called “Factors Needed to Make Money in the Stock Market.”
Sixteen points. No formulas, no forecasts.
1. Price and Value
Rule 1. “Price is the most important factor to use in relation to value.”
Rule 2. Work out what the company is worth. A share is a slice of a real business, not a piece of paper.
Rule 3. Book value is the starting point for that number. Make sure debt isn’t as big as the equity.
Rule 11. He’d rather buy assets at a discount than buy earnings. Earnings can swing hard in a short time, assets usually move slowly, and buying on earnings means you need to know the company far better.
This is where I part ways with Schloss the most.
Most of what I write about gets bought on earnings, and often on earnings that haven’t arrived yet. Rule 11 explains why my write-ups run as long as they do. If the case rests on earnings, I need to understand the business well enough to know why they’ll show up.
Rule 1 still holds for me without any changes. A great business at the wrong price is a bad position, and it’s the reason a lot of names sit on my watch list for months before they go anywhere near the portfolio.
2. Temperament
Rule 4. Be patient. Stocks don’t go up straight away.
Rule 6. It’s fine to be on your own, as long as you’ve gone looking for the holes in your own reasoning. Buy in stages as the price falls and sell in stages as it rises.
Rule 7. Once the decision is made, have the nerve to stick with it.
Rule 8. Pick a philosophy and follow it.
Rule 13. Keep emotions out of it. Fear and greed do the most damage.
Rule 6 is the one I come back to most.
The line about looking for weaknesses in your own thinking is the reason every SC Elevator Pitch has a “What Would Change My Mind” section. Writing down what would break the thesis before I own the stock means I already know what I’m looking for when the results come out.
Rules 7 and 8 sound like the easy ones. In practice they’re hard, because a philosophy only gets tested when it’s underperforming, which is exactly when it feels wrong.
3. Buying and Selling
Rule 5. Don’t buy on tips or for a quick move. Don’t sell just because there’s bad news.
Rule 9. Don’t rush to sell. Selling at a fair price is fine, but a 50% gain on its own isn’t a reason. Before selling, look at the company again against its book value and check the mood of the market. Are yields low and P/Es high? Is everyone optimistic?
Rule 10. It helps to buy near the low of the past few years. A stock that went from 20 to 125 and back to 60 can still fall a long way.
The SCR watch list is built along the lines of Rule 10. I’m looking for companies that have pulled back while the thesis keeps working, not ones that are making new highs.
The “sell on a scale up” part of Rule 6 is how I handled Ashtead Technology. After the takeover bid it had grown to about 31% of the model portfolio. On 19 October I trimmed it to about 15% and held the rest as cash.
Schloss didn’t always get the selling right himself. He bought Lehman Brothers below book value shortly after it listed in 1994 and made 75% in a few months, and the stock then went on to triple. He bought the cement company Southdown at $12.50 and sold it at around $28 to $30 within two years. It later got to $70.
He was one of the best investors of the century and still sold too early. There’s no clean rule for selling, only a process you can live with when it costs you.
4. Money
Rule 12. Listen to people you respect, but you don’t have to take their advice. It’s your money, keeping it is harder than making it, and big losses are hard to win back.
Rule 14. Remember how compounding works. At 12% a year your money doubles in about six years, before tax. Divide 72 by your return to get the number of years it takes to double.
Rule 15. Prefer stocks to bonds. Bonds cap your gains and inflation eats into what you get back.
Rule 16. Be careful with leverage. It can turn against you.
Rules 12 and 16 are really one rule. A 50% loss needs a 100% gain to get back to even, and leverage is the quickest way to end up with a 50% loss.
Rule 14 is the one that ties the whole list together.
The $805 versus $88 gap at the top of this post came from five extra points a year, held for 47 years. None of his other rules mattered as much as staying in the game long enough for that to happen.
What Isn’t on the List
There’s nothing here about meeting management, forecasting growth, or calling the market.
That was deliberate. Schloss knew he wasn’t good at reading executives or predicting earnings, so he left them out and built around assets instead. He also spread his money wide. Buffett once said Walter owned well over 100 stocks at a time.
My portfolio looks very different. It’s more concentrated, and it leans on earnings in a way he wouldn’t have.
What I take from him is less about the specific rules and more that they fit the person using them. He wrote down a process he could actually stick to for 47 years, and then he stuck to it.
I hope you enjoyed today’s post.
Have a great week ahead,
Dom
Schwar Capital Research
Disclaimer: The content provided in this newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or other professional advice. The opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Schwar Capital. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The author may or may not hold positions in the stocks or other financial instruments mentioned. Always do your own research or consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. You can see our full disclaimer here.


